Sir John Everett Millais – The Controversy Begins

In the last post on Art Nouveau, we met Christina Rossetti, the sister of Dante, one of the founders of the Pre-Raphaelite movement.

The Pre-Raphaelites were revolutionary for their time.  But are they still relevant to our time?  How have seven men, who lived in a different century, changed our world?

The answer lies with their personal narratives, which were reflected and magnified in their artistic productivity.  Their lives were remarkable!  They were radicals, unafraid to challenge anything and everything that had the feel or smell of status quo.  A true brotherhood, they fed on each other’s brilliance.

The status quo responded with predictable outrage.  The critics were offended, indignant, infuriated….but alas, the world was ready for the movement.  Audiences were captivated by the beauty of the women, challenged by the symbolism and enticed by the social, moral and political upheaval generated by their exhibitions.

The brotherhood came together in 1848 at the Gower Street, London home of John Millais’s parents. It started with three: William Holman Hunt, John Everett Millais and Dante Gabriel Rossetti.  William Michael Rossetti (Dante’s brother), James Collinson, Frederic George Stephens and Thomas Woolner followed shortly thereafter to form the group of seven.

It didn’t take long for the Pre-Raphaelite’s to stir the controversial flames beginning with John Millais’s painting: Christ in the House of His Parents.   Blasphemy!  Critics were appalled. Charles Dickens considered Mary to be ugly and accused John Millais of portraying her as an alcoholic.  It must have been a tense moment, especially since Millais used his sister-in-law, Mary Hodgkinson, as the model. John Ruskin, the leading English critic of  the Victorian era, came to the rescue with a letter to the press, but even he disliked the painting.

Out of controversy comes debate.  And when there is debate, there is discussion and communication.  Perhaps that is the greatest legacy of the Pre-Raphaelites.

“It doesn’t matter how beautifully a thing is painted, it is no good if it isn’t right – it’s got to come out… What does it matter how you do it? Paint it with a shovel if you can’t get your effect any other way.”

Sir John Everett Millais

4 Replies to “Sir John Everett Millais – The Controversy Begins”

  1. Hi, I was looking for the subject art nouveau in my reader and found your blog. After looking through your posts, I found in your gallery the window of belvedere palace in Vienna. I posted a post on that window as I found another blogger featuring the window at Freer Gallery. If you are interested, this is the link to that blog.

    I also have another blog on art nouveau. Would like to follow and learn from you!


    1. Thank you for joining the conversation and for linking me to your blog as well as “My Notebook.” (I’m following both) Belvedere Palace is extraordinary. I am looking forward to our ongoing dialogue – we can learn from each other, which, in my opinion, is the best part of blogging.


  2. Loved the Brotherhood since I discovered them at ten. I also love Burne Jones, and Sir Frederick Leighton, Drinkwater and Watts….


    1. The “Brotherhood” – just the name sparks excitement. These men were (and still are) a powerful influence as evidenced by the Pinterest collections I came across in the last couple of days. I am looking more closely at the women in their lives and the stories behind their artwork. Thank you so much for stopping by – great to share the joy of artistic endeavours.


You're welcome to join the dialogue!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.